Open Letter from Doctors in England to the House of Lords

Reproduced from:

Today, I have read an open letter addressed to the House of Lords. I have permission from Kailash Chand to reproduce it.

“As doctors in England, we are writing to you to express our conviction that the Health and Social Care Bill will irreparably undermine the most important and admirable principles of the National Health Service, and to appeal for its rejection by the House of Lords.

Because it is universal and comprehensive, and publicly accountable, and because clinical decisions are made without regard for financial gain, the NHS is rightly regarded all over the world as the benchmark for fairness and equity in healthcare provision.

The transfer of services to private, profit-making companies will result in loss of public accountability and a damaging focus instead on low-risk areas that are financially profitable. A confused patchwork of competing providers will deliver a fragmented and inequitable service and any reliance on personal health budgets or insurance policies will further increase inequality. Because there will be a financial incentive for providing treatment patients will be over-treated, the potential costs of which are limitless. And the possibility of the commissioning role being outsourced to the private sector is also deeply concerning.

In forcing through this ill-conceived Bill, without an electoral mandate and against the strident objections of healthcare professionals, the Government is also ignoring overwhelming evidence that healthcare markets are inefficient and expensive to administer.

The public has been misled throughout, first by claims that no major reorganisation of the NHS would be undertaken, later by repeated denials that what is happening represents privatisation, and furthermore by suggestions that the Bill enjoys the support of the medical profession. We do not accept the argument that “things have already gone too far” – the enactment of some of the Bill’s proposals has been premature and illegal, however some of its most damaging aspects may still be mitigated.

We believe that on moral, clinical and economic grounds, the Health and Social Care Bill must be rejected.”

Just this week, 400 Public Health experts wrote to the Lords warning that the plans “will do irreparable harm to the NHS, to individual patients and to society as a whole.”The more people Lords hear from the better – let’s send our own personal messages now.

 Check out 38degrees new “contact a Lord” tool, and write your message now: Sign the Petition!

1 thought on “Open Letter from Doctors in England to the House of Lords

  1. Pingback: Lord Owen : if this Bill is introduced, in ten years’ time the NHS will be unrecognisable. « Wyre Forest Labour Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s